Introduction:
In recent years, there has been a growing discussion about the middle class in Africa, with development actors, financial experts, and academics focusing on its significance for development and democratization.
However, the concept of the middle class in Africa has faced criticism for its lack of empirical evidence and its uncritical adoption of Western notions.
To address these concerns, scholars have initiated a more nuanced and context-specific exploration of the African middle class and its relationship with social protest.
This post delves into the key issues surrounding the middle class discourse in Africa and highlights the importance of an intersectional and multidimensional approach.
Heterogeneity and Historical Trajectories:
African societies are diverse and have distinct historical trajectories compared to Europe and North America, where the concept of the middle class originated.
The development of middle classes in these regions was influenced by specific economic and cultural conditions, such as industrialization and the emergence of nuclear families.
Comparing the situation of middle-income groups in Africa to their Western counterparts requires careful consideration of these divergent backgrounds.
Political Orientation and Pro-Democratic Views:
Contrary to the assumption that a middle-income position correlates with a pro-democratic orientation, historical evidence suggests that middle classes have displayed both conservative and liberal tendencies.
The association of the middle class with pro-democratic worldviews was not consistently true in Europe and North America, and this complexity should be taken into account when studying the African middle class.
Challenging Eurocentric Scholarship:
The dominance of European and North American research in academia has marginalized African contexts and limited the development of theories and empirical research on Africa.
International disciplinary debates often perceive African studies as mere area studies, neglecting the depth and complexity of social structures in Africa.
Addressing this knowledge gap and challenging the Eurocentric bias requires a concerted effort to bring African perspectives to the forefront.
Toward a Nuanced Approach:
Despite the critiques, studying the middle class and protest in Africa holds great promise. With ongoing political and economic changes, new groups of middle-income earners are emerging across the continent.
To better understand this phenomenon, a multidimensional and intersectional approach is necessary. Factors such as extended family structures, ethnicity, political networks, and socio-cultural positioning must be considered.
By adopting this nuanced approach, researchers can contribute to a more comprehensive and less Eurocentric debate on the African middle class.
Read the original version of this article here.